News & Coverage
Commentary & Writers
Local coverage. Independent commentary. Republican perspectives.Explore all news →

How Maryland’s Higher Education System Became a Machine for Debt, Bureaucracy, and Broken Promises

What they never say at freshman orientation. Nobody hands you a glossy brochure that reads: “Welcome to the most expensive purchase of your life. You may not finish on time. The degree you choose may not pay enough to cover the loans you are about to sign. And no one here will lose sleep over your debt.” They show you the climbing wall. They show you the gourmet dining hall. They show you the lazy river at some competing school and promise theirs is better. They do not show you the bill.
That is the racket. And in Maryland, it is running at full speed.
At the University of Maryland, College Park, an in-state freshman in the 1989 to 1990 academic year paid roughly $6,424 for an entire year of education, housing, and meals.[1] Today that same student will pay more than $33,000. Out-of-state students now face costs exceeding $63,000 per year.[2]
That is not inflation. Inflation would have pushed the 1989 cost to somewhere around $17,000 today. What families are looking at is more than twice the inflation-adjusted figure. This is a system that has chosen to be expensive. And it is making that choice on behalf of families who had very little say in the matter.
The parents who are cashing out retirement accounts to cover tuition are not victims of a natural economic force. They are victims of an industry that learned it could raise prices indefinitely because the federal government would keep expanding the lending to cover the gap. The students signing those loan documents are not making free choices. They are making coerced choices inside a market deliberately insulated from the normal pressures that keep prices honest.
Maryland deserves better. And the good news, which the university lobby will not advertise, is that better is available. We know what works. Other states are doing it. The only thing stopping Maryland is the institutional will to demand accountability rather than write bigger checks to the same broken system.
This is a system that has chosen to be expensive. And it is making that choice on behalf of families who had very little say in the matter.
THE ADMINISTRATIVE EXPLOSION NOBODY WANTS TO TALK ABOUT
Ask a university president why tuition has quintupled and you will receive a well-rehearsed answer about declining state support. It is a compelling story. It is also incomplete.
State appropriations for higher education have fluctuated over the decades. But studies from the American Enterprise Institute and the Heritage Foundation have documented something the universities prefer to ignore: administrative staffing at American colleges grew far faster than instructional staffing between 2010 and 2018.[3]
Modern universities now maintain armies of professionals who have nothing to do with teaching anybody anything. Compliance offices. Branding divisions. Institutional effectiveness coordinators. Student experience managers. Diversity, equity, and inclusion administrators multiplied across every department and sub-department of the campus bureaucracy. Strategic initiative teams whose strategic initiative appears to be the perpetuation of the strategic initiative team.
Every one of those positions comes with a salary, benefits, office space, travel budget, technology support, and a support staff of their own. Every one of those costs flows directly to tuition. The student borrowing $40,000 a year is not just paying for professors and classrooms. That student is subsidizing an administrative apparatus that would have been unrecognizable to the university presidents of a generation ago.
This is not a partisan talking point. It is arithmetic. When non-instructional spending grows faster than instructional spending, the cost per classroom hour rises while the value per classroom hour stays flat or falls. That is a bad deal for students and families. It is a great deal for the administrative class collecting the paychecks.
Maryland lawmakers should demand a full administrative staffing audit at every public university in the state. Not a report prepared by the universities themselves. An independent audit. How many non-instructional positions exist today compared to 2000? How much of every tuition dollar goes to classroom instruction versus institutional management? Families deserve to know what they are actually buying.
THE FEDERAL LENDING MACHINE THAT ATE THE MARKET
No honest accounting of the higher education affordability crisis can omit the role of federal student lending. The expansion of federally guaranteed student loans created one of the most straightforward market distortions in modern American economic history.[4]
When a consumer can borrow essentially unlimited funds to purchase a product while bearing no immediate price sensitivity, the seller has no market reason to control costs. Universities discovered this dynamic decades ago and have been exploiting it ever since. Federal student lending did not create educational access for free. It created access while exporting the cost onto future graduates and, increasingly, onto taxpayers when forgiveness programs socialize the loss.
The Heritage Foundation has argued for reducing federal lending caps, phasing out Parent PLUS loans, and dismantling the policy architecture that allows universities to raise prices in lockstep with whatever Washington is willing to lend. Those arguments are correct. An institution that knows the federal government will back whatever price it sets has no incentive to compete on value. It will compete on amenities, on rankings, on prestige signals that justify ever-higher sticker prices to families who are told they cannot afford not to pay.
Parent PLUS loans deserve particular scrutiny. Parents borrowing six figures at federal interest rates to send their children to residential universities represent a quiet debt crisis that gets far less attention than undergraduate borrowing. These are families who in many cases will carry this debt into retirement. The program rewards universities and punishes the families it was supposedly designed to help.
Real affordability reform requires addressing the lending structure, not layering more subsidy programs on top of a price-inflated system. Adding another scholarship fund to a university charging $63,000 a year is not a solution. It is a rebate on a transaction that should never have cost that much in the first place.
Real affordability reform requires addressing the lending structure, not layering more subsidy programs on top of a price-inflated system.
THE TEXAS MODEL MARYLAND REFUSES TO IMITATE
In 2011, then-Governor Rick Perry issued a challenge to Texas public universities: create a bachelor’s degree that costs students $10,000 or less, including textbooks.[5]
The academic establishment reacted with the particular mix of condescension and horror it reserves for proposals that threaten comfortable arrangements. The idea was dismissed as unrealistic, ideologically driven, incompatible with quality. The professors and presidents who mocked it were the same people overseeing systems charging six figures for four years of undergraduate education.
What actually happened is instructive. Texas universities experimented. Texas A&M University-Commerce developed competency-based bachelor’s degree programs. Western Governors University Texas expanded access to affordable online credentials. Community college partnerships multiplied. Employers got involved in shaping curriculum. The conversation about what a degree actually needed to cost shifted fundamentally.
The goal was not to cheapen education. The goal was to expose the unnecessary costs baked into the standard residential degree model and challenge institutions to eliminate them. There is a critical difference between academic rigor and administrative overhead, between genuine educational investment and the prestige spending that inflates tuition without improving learning outcomes.
Maryland should launch its own version. A Maryland $10,000 Degree Initiative, built through partnerships between the University System of Maryland and the state’s community college network, focused initially on high-demand fields where workforce need is urgent and documented.[6]
Cybersecurity. Information technology. Nursing support tracks. Accounting. Logistics. These are not niche fields. These are the backbone of Maryland’s economy and the domains where employers are actively struggling to fill positions. A student completing a $10,000 pathway into a cybersecurity career is better served than a student completing a $120,000 credential in a field with uncertain employment demand.
FLORIDA’S LESSON: ACCOUNTABILITY PRODUCES RESULTS
Florida has built one of the most consistently affordable and accountable public university systems in America. That did not happen by accident.[7]
Florida policymakers made deliberate choices. They tied state funding to measurable outcomes, including graduation rates, workforce placement, and degree productivity. They strengthened transfer pathways between community colleges and four-year institutions, ensuring that students who spent two years at lower-cost schools could complete bachelor’s degrees without losing credits, repeating coursework, or adding semesters.
Institutions respond to incentives. This is not a controversial observation. It is one of the few propositions in economics that commands near-universal agreement. If state funding rewards enrollment growth regardless of graduation rates, universities will chase enrollment. If state funding rewards six-year completion and job placement, universities will focus on graduation and employment. Florida chose the latter. Maryland has been slower to make that choice, and families are paying the cost of that hesitation.
Maryland possesses excellent community college infrastructure. Montgomery College. Prince George’s Community College. Anne Arundel Community College. Howard Community College. These institutions have served hundreds of thousands of Maryland residents and represent some of the best value in state-supported education. The problem is that the transfer pathway between these schools and Maryland’s four-year universities remains cluttered with inefficiencies that cost students time and money.
Students lose credits that were supposed to transfer. They are forced to repeat courses they already completed. They extend their graduation timelines by one or two semesters, adding thousands of dollars in additional tuition and living expenses. A truly seamless transfer system would guarantee universal credit recognition, publish clear four-year degree completion maps for every major, and hold institutions accountable when students are forced off track through administrative failure rather than academic struggle.
Maryland should make seamless transfer a legal guarantee, not an aspiration. Every credit earned at an accredited Maryland community college should apply to the corresponding four-year degree without negotiation, without petition, and without the kind of institutional obstruction that currently forces too many transfer students to pay for the same education twice.
Maryland should make seamless transfer a legal guarantee, not an aspiration.
THE DEGREE DECISION NOBODY IS HELPING STUDENTS MAKE
There is an argument that the higher education industry does not want anyone to make publicly because it undermines a considerable portion of the enrollment revenue model. Not all degrees produce comparable financial outcomes. And students deserve to know that before they borrow $80,000.
This is not hostility toward the liberal arts. Broad education matters. Critical thinking, written communication, civic understanding, and historical perspective produce better employees, better citizens, and better human beings. That argument stands on its own merits and I do not dismiss it.
But a student has the right to know that the median starting salary for graduates in their intended field, at their specific institution, given their specific credential, is likely to be a particular number. They have the right to understand that a debt-to-income ratio above a certain threshold tends to produce chronic financial hardship regardless of passion or purpose. They have the right to make an informed decision rather than a romanticized one.
Universities currently have very little incentive to volunteer this information clearly. They market outcomes at the positive tail of the distribution. They feature the successful alum, not the median graduate. They present selective employment data without contextualizing total debt. Transparency requirements would force a more honest conversation.
Maryland should require every public university to publish, prominently and accessibly, the following for each degree program: average time to graduation, median debt at graduation, median first-year earnings, and five-year employment rates.[8]
Engineering fields, particularly mechanical, electrical, aerospace, chemical, and civil engineering, consistently produce strong starting salaries and robust career trajectories. Computer science and cybersecurity, especially relevant in the Maryland region given the density of federal agencies, defense contractors, and technology firms, offer some of the fastest financial returns in higher education. Nursing and healthcare professions remain structurally resilient. Accounting provides stable demand across government, corporate, and financial sectors.
These fields should be highlighted. Transfer pathways into these fields should be prioritized. Scholarship structures should reflect workforce demand. None of this prevents students from pursuing other fields. It simply ensures that the choice is an informed one.
THE COURSE REQUIREMENT PROBLEM
The University of Maryland’s original CORE general education program, implemented in 1990, required approximately 43 to 46 credits of coursework outside the major. Today’s General Education system at UMD includes Fundamental Studies, Distributive Studies, Big Question courses, and Diversity requirements, layering a substantial credit burden onto students who must also satisfy major requirements and electives.[9]
The question is not whether students should receive broad educational exposure. They should. The question is whether every credit requirement, every mandatory course layer, every new distribution category added over the decades serves educational purpose or institutional purpose.
Additional requirements mean additional semesters. Additional semesters mean additional tuition. Additional tuition means additional debt. Every course added to a degree map is a financial decision as much as it is a pedagogical one. Universities that treat general education expansion as cost-free are being dishonest about the burden they are imposing on students and families.
Maryland should require universities to justify every mandatory credit in general education requirements against clear educational outcome criteria. Requirements that cannot demonstrate their value in terms of student learning, workforce readiness, or civic development should be consolidated or eliminated. Graduating in three and a half years rather than four and a half years is worth thousands of dollars to a Maryland family. That math deserves to be taken seriously.
WHAT MARYLAND SHOULD DO
The path forward is not complicated. It requires political will to challenge institutions with significant lobbying power and long memories for political disfavor. It requires the courage to tell universities that their current cost structures are unacceptable and that the state’s resources will follow outcomes rather than prestige.
Maryland should create a $10,000 degree initiative through community college and University System partnerships targeting cybersecurity, information technology, nursing support tracks, accounting, and logistics. The state should require independent administrative staffing audits at every public university with mandatory public reporting. It should mandate seamless transfer credit guarantees across the community college and four-year university system.
A meaningful percentage of higher education appropriations should be tied to graduation rates, workforce placement rates, and debt-to-income outcomes for graduates. Every public university should be required to publish comprehensive outcome data by major, prominently and accessibly, on every admissions and financial aid page. Dual enrollment programs that allow high school students to bank college credits before they ever pay a dime in university tuition should be expanded aggressively. Mandatory student fees should be capped and subjected to legislative review before universities can impose new ones.
Three-year degree pathways for academically prepared students should be piloted at Maryland’s flagship institutions. Online and hybrid instruction should be deployed strategically as cost-reduction tools, not gimmicks, with quality standards and student outcome tracking to ensure the savings are real and passed through to students. Apprenticeship and credential pathways in skilled trades and technical fields should be elevated in public discourse rather than treated as consolation prizes for students who could not manage a four-year degree.
None of these reforms eliminate the value of higher education. All of them restore the connection between investment and outcome that used to define American higher education at its best.
RESTORING THE LADDER
There is a sentimental version of the higher education story that university presidents like to tell at commencement. Education lifts families. It opens doors. It expands the possible. It builds the middle class and sustains democracy. They are not wrong about any of it, in the abstract.
The problem is that a system charging $33,000 a year for in-state students and $63,000 for out-of-state students is not building the middle class. It is taxing it. It is taking families who believed in the promise of upward mobility and demanding a price that middle-income households increasingly cannot absorb without mortgaging their futures. The families who earn enough to be ineligible for substantial grant aid but not enough to comfortably write these checks are bearing the full weight of this failure.
The purpose of public higher education is not to sustain an administrative class. It is not to fund a prestige competition among institutional brands. It is not to provide luxury amenities to eighteen-year-olds on borrowed money. The purpose of public higher education is to give working families, middle-class families, first-generation students, and anyone with the drive and capability to improve their circumstances a genuine pathway to do it.
That is what the system used to provide. That is what it stopped providing when it decided that growth, bureaucracy, and amenities mattered more than affordability and outcomes. And that is what it can provide again if Maryland’s policymakers stop pretending the current model is a victim of circumstances rather than a product of choices.
The climbing wall was a choice. The administrative expansion was a choice. The tuition increases were choices. The insulation from accountability was a choice. Every one of those choices can be reversed. The families paying the bills deserve a system that is finally willing to make different ones.
Maryland can be a national leader in fixing this. Or Maryland can keep writing apologetic press releases about affordability while cashing the checks of an unreformed system.
The choice, as always, belongs to the people we elect to make it.
ENDNOTES
[1] University of Maryland Historical Cost Data, IPEDS Data Center, National Center for Education Statistics. https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/datacenter
[2] University of Maryland Cost of Attendance 2025-2026, Office of Student Financial Aid. https://financialaid.umd.edu/cost-of-attendance
[3] Administrative Bloat at American Universities, American Enterprise Institute. https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/administrative-bloat-in-american-universities
[4] The Federal Student Loan Program and the Inflation of College Costs, Heritage Foundation. https://www.heritage.org/education/report/the-federal-student-loan-program-and-the-inflation-college-costs
[5] Rick Perry’s $10,000 College Degree Challenge, Texas Tribune. https://www.texastribune.org/2011/10/25/perry-10000-college-degree-challenge
[6] University System of Maryland Community College Transfer Agreements. https://www.usmd.edu/usm/academicaffairs/transfer
[7] Florida University System Performance Funding Model, Florida Board of Governors. https://www.flbog.edu/about/budget/performance-funding
[8] College Transparency Act and Student Outcomes Data, National Student Clearinghouse Research Center. https://nscresearchcenter.org/college-transparency-act
[9] University of Maryland General Education Requirements, Office of Undergraduate Studies. https://gened.umd.edu/requirements
Carol Hughes is a Contributing Editor for Direct Line News covering education policy, fiscal accountability, and Maryland politics.
Direct Line News is a Maryland-based free-access publication committed to the Republican reform tradition.