STILL CRAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS

Listen to this article now
POWERED BY DIGITAL PIZZA AUDIO
00:00 04:28
Reading Time: 4 minutes
Satirical vintage album-cover graphic featuring George McGovern and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez with the headline “Still Crazy After All These Years,” illustrating the article’s comparison of the Democratic Party’s progressive politics across generations.
Profile photo of Jacob Silver
Jacob Silver Senior Contributor

There is a song the Democratic National Committee should consider for its next convention. Not a thumping arena anthem. Not something focus-tested for suburban swing voters. Paul Simon already wrote the number in 1975: “Still Crazy After All These Years.” The title alone does most of the work.

This is not an argument that every Democrat is crazy, just a good majority of them. Look at the evidence: FDR, George McGovern, and pick any nut from the left side of the aisle in Congress.

THE McGOVERN WARNING

George McGovern, a failed candidate for President.  Provides the obvious starting point. In 1972, Democrats nominated a candidate identified with the party’s antiwar and liberal activist wing. President Richard Nixon won 520 electoral votes to McGovern’s 17. McGovern carried Massachusetts and the District of Columbia. President Nixon carried everything else. That was not a narrow loss. It was a political alarm bell loud enough to rattle windows.

Democrats eventually recovered because successful politicians learned from the electorate. Bill Clinton, an offshoot of the ATARI Democrats, did not run as McGovernite. Clinton had better television ads. He talked about fiscal discipline, work, opportunity and a government that had to prove it could deliver. There is a lesson in that. Parties win durable majorities when they listen.  But let’s be real: Clinton, or, as my Dad called him, “Clownton,” was only good because of the 104th Congress that reigned in the crazy.

THE OLD IDEA IN NEW PACKAGING

Today, however, the activist Left is again selling an expansive vision of government. The Democratic Socialists of America’s current program calls for universal health care at no cost to individuals, publicly owned social housing, universal rent control, free public education from pre-K through college, cancellation of student debt, and a 32-hour workweek with full pay and benefits.

Supporters can defend those proposals. They should.  After all, they OWN them.  A republic needs arguments, not slogans.  It ius a good thing we have a vibrant Republican Party that offers bold distinction from the days of George McGovern’s Big Government, nanny-state worldview, to today’s DSA.

That is where good governance matters.  Conservatism is not merely saying no.  It is recognizing that public money belongs to the public (that is, you, the People), that incentives matter, that bureaucracy has limits, tand that compassion without arithmetic eventually sends somebody a bill.

STILL CRAZY?

The joke practically writes itself. The labels have changed. “Liberal” became “progressive.” Spending became “investment.” Government expansion became “economic justice.” Socialism acquired the friendlier modifier “democratic.” Yet the recurring proposition remains familiar: give government more money, more authority and more responsibility, and this time it will deliver the promised result.

Republicans answer not with hysteria.  They answer it with receipts. Show the cost. Measure the outcome. Demand accountability. Protect the safety net for people who genuinely need it, while refusing to pretend that every social problem can be solved by creating another permanent program in Washington, Annapolis or city hall.

Paul Simon released “Still Crazy After All These Years” in October 1975, three years after McGovern’s defeat. Simon was writing about something else entirely, of course. Politics has supplied the title with an unexpectedly long second career.

If Democrats want to move toward the center, embrace competent government and rediscover fiscal restraint, Republicans should welcome the competition. The country benefits when both parties are serious.

But if the party’s activist wing keeps reaching backward for bigger versions of ideas Americans have questioned for half a century, Republicans need only point to the record and ask a simple question.

How many years does an idea have to fail before trying it again stops being progress?  Oh wait, that’s the definition of Insanity.  Hence their Slogan “Still Crazy…”.

Republicans Coming to Take them Away, Ha-Haaa!


ENDNOTES

1. National Archives, “1972 Electoral College Results.” https://www.archives.gov/electoral-college/1972

2. The American Presidency Project, “1972 Presidential Election.” https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/statistics/elections/1972

3. Democratic Socialists of America, “Our Program” (2026). https://program.dsausa.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/WDM-Program.pdf

4. Paul Simon Official Site, “Still Crazy After All These Years.” https://www.paulsimon.com/en-ca/music/still-crazy-after-all-these-years/

About The Author

Scroll to Top