Maryland’s Watchdogs Need the Records to Do Their Jobs

Listen to this article now
POWERED BY DIGITAL PIZZA AUDIO
00:00 05:06
Reading Time: 4 minutes
Maryland flag colors frame a headline reading “Let Maryland’s Watchdogs Work,” above government buildings, public records folders, a magnifying glass and an open filing cabinet.
Profile photo of Trent Anderson
Trent Anderson Senior Contributor

An inspector general should not have to spend months fighting for the paperwork needed to inspect government.

Yet here we are in Maryland, watching public officials argue over whether the people hired to investigate waste, fraud, and abuse can actually examine the records. Baltimore City has been fighting in court. Howard County is considering a legislative fix. Montgomery County’s watchdog has raised the same alarm.

Taxpayers ought to be asking a simple question: How did access become optional?

Howard County’s Council Bill 69-2026, sponsored by Deb Jung, would designate the inspector general as a custodian of county government records and revise the office’s duties. Introduced October 5, it is scheduled for a public hearing October 19.¹

In the FOX45 report, Inspector General Kelly Madigan explained that restrictions on certain records make her job difficult. She was careful not to assign blame, saying she did not necessarily believe the administration was acting in bad faith.

It leaves the central problem standing. Whether a roadblock comes from hostility, confusion, or legal interpretation, the investigator still cannot get through it.

Council Chair Opel Jones tried to reject the bill at introduction, citing legal sufficiency. The report says his effort failed.

If the legislation has a legal defect, identify it and propose a workable correction.  Residents deserve to hear how the county will preserve effective oversight.  Stopping a proposal without resolving the access problem leaves them paying for an office whose work can be restricted.

Baltimore shows how expensive and bitter this dispute can become.

Inspector General Isabel Mercedes Cumming challenged restrictions imposed by Mayor Brandon Scott’s administration. Circuit Court Judge Pamela White ordered the city to comply with subpoenas and restore access to records and computer systems. The administration appealed, arguing that the order did not adequately secure sensitive material.²

Those legal concerns deserve examination. Personnel information, confidential financial records and privileged communications call for careful handling. But invoking confidentiality cannot settle every dispute in favor of the government being investigated.

The Baltimore fight reached a contempt motion on September 28. Cumming’s lawyers alleged that the city had failed to restore access as ordered. On October 1, they withdrew that motion after Cumming reported that her office had regained access.³

That update matters. It also raises an uncomfortable question: Why did restoring a watchdog’s ability to work require this much litigation?

Montgomery County residents should pay attention.

In February, Inspector General Megan Davey Limarzi said a county department had denied her office information by citing an exception in the Maryland Public Information Act. She said records of that type had previously been provided without question. That was her account of the denial, and it should be treated as such.⁴

The stakes extend well beyond an argument between lawyers. Montgomery County’s inspector general has published reviews involving MCPS complaint processing, electric bus contract management, procurement and background screening. These are matters affecting public money, school operations and confidence in local institutions.⁵

An investigator needs the underlying evidence to determine what happened. A comforting statement from the department under review cannot do that.

The three jurisdictions are connected by more than geography. Limarzi, Cumming and Madigan joined Baltimore County’s deputy inspector general in a statement warning that an attorney general’s advice letter could undermine their entry to essential records. They asked state lawmakers to clarify the law and stressed their existing obligation to protect confidential information.⁶

That distinction should guide the solution.  Giving an authorized investigator access does not mean publishing someone’s personnel file.

Maryland should create clear rules for investigative access, confidentiality, and expeditious resolution of legitimate privilege disputes. Local councils should strengthen workable protections while Annapolis addresses uncertainty in state law.

Republicans should press that case consistently, including when scrutiny reaches  Republican officials.  Independent oversight earns its credibility by following the evidence wherever it leads.

Taxpayers fund the departments, the lawyers and the inspectors general. They deserve a system that lets investigators finish their work.

Howard County has an opportunity to move that system forward. Baltimore has demonstrated the cost of a prolonged fight. Montgomery County has warned that the problem travels.

The records should reach the people authorized to examine them.


Endnotes

  1. Howard County Council   Council Bill 69-2026: Legislation Details.
    https://apps.howardcountymd.gov/olis/LegislationDetail/15196/CB69-2026
  2. Maryland Daily Record   “Baltimore mayor appeals order restoring IG’s records access.” September 22, 2026.
    https://thedailyrecord.com/2026/09/22/baltimore-mayor-appeals-order-inspector-general-records-access/
  3. Baltimore Brew   “Baltimore Inspector General asks judge to hold Scott administration in contempt.” September 28, 2026; updated October 1.
    https://www.baltimorebrew.com/2026/09/28/breaking-baltimore-inspector-general-asks-judge-to-hold-scott-administration-in-civil-contempt/
  4. Montgomery Perspective   “Inspector General: County Government Has Denied Access to Information.” February 16, 2026.
    https://montgomeryperspective.com/2026/02/16/inspector-general-county-government-has-denied-access-to-information/
  5. Montgomery County Office of the Inspector General   Publications.
    https://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/OIG/igproduct.html
  6. “Local Inspectors General Respond to OAG Advice Letter on MPIA”   Joint Statement.
    https://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/OIG/Resources/Files/PDF/IGNewsRelease/2026/Statement-IGs-OAGAdviceLetterMPIA_final.pdf

About The Author

Scroll to Top