News & Coverage
Commentary & Writers
Local coverage. Independent commentary. Republican perspectives.Explore all news →

Marc Elrich’s weekly message on the Wootton High School shooting was polished, sympathetic, and completely predictable. He called it “horrible,” thanked a long list of agencies, promoted the county crisis center number, and closed with the usual talking points about “sensible gun laws” and more mental health resources. In other words, it was the kind of statement that makes government feel busy without making families feel safer.
But if we are being honest, Montgomery County did not just “experience” this moment. We helped manufacture the conditions for it. We made political choices about school safety, and those choices had consequences.
This was a self-inflicted event in the most literal policy sense.
For years, Montgomery County had School Resource Officers in high schools. Not as a magic shield. Not as a substitute for counseling. As one layer in a layered safety strategy. Then the county leadership ended that model. And what replaced it was not “better.” It was thinner, slower, and farther away.
WTOP reports that in 2021, the county ended the embedded SRO program and moved to a cluster-based model, the Community Engagement Officer approach, where police are assigned across multiple schools rather than stationed inside each high school. MyMCMedia reported that the program “was changed” so officers were no longer stationed in a particular school, and that at the time of the Wootton shooting, the officer assigned to Wootton’s cluster was dealing with an issue at a different school.
That is not a small detail. That is the whole argument.
When seconds matter, being “assigned to a cluster” is not the same as being on site. When a weapon comes out in a hallway, the difference between inside the building and across the neighborhood is not academic. It is life and death.
And it is not just Republicans saying that. Montgomery County State’s Attorney John McCarthy said it plainly after the bond hearing: “It was a terrible mistake to take the SROs out of our schools.” He pointed out that the county has now had two school shootings since SROs were removed.
Let’s pause there. The county’s chief prosecutor is telling you that the policy change was a mistake and linking it to real events in our schools. He is not making a theoretical argument. He is looking at the trajectory and saying we got this wrong.
So why does Elrich’s message feel so evasive? Because it is.
He warns against “oversimplifying” school safety, as if the public is too emotional to understand complexity. But parents are not asking for a doctoral seminar. They are asking why the most basic, visible deterrent and rapid response presence was pulled out of schools and replaced with a model that can leave a high school uncovered at the exact wrong moment.
Then comes the rhetorical pivot: guns are the problem, ghost guns are the problem, and therefore the answer is more advocacy for gun laws plus more mental health investment. Fine. Ghost guns are a problem. But that does not excuse stripping away an on-site safety layer that existed for a reason. Both things can be true at the same time.
And here is where the county’s own paper trail matters. The county produced an official analysis around eliminating SROs that explicitly framed the goal as removing police from schools and redirecting resources toward mental health and social-emotional learning supports. That may have sounded compassionate in a press release. But compassion without security is just vibes. And our kids do not attend school inside a talking point.
This is not an argument against counselors. It is an argument against pretending that counselors can do the job of law enforcement when violence happens. A social worker cannot intercept a weapon in real time. A therapist cannot detain a suspect. A restorative justice circle cannot stop a gunshot. Those supports are valuable, but they are not substitutes for an on-site, trained officer whose job includes prevention, deterrence, and immediate response.
McCarthy also made the case in a way most parents intuitively understand: good SROs build relationships. They deter crime. They learn the rhythms of a building. They notice patterns. They hear things before they explode. That relationship building is not a bonus feature. It is part of prevention.
So here is the Republican bottom line. We need School Resource Officers in every Montgomery County high school, and we should seriously evaluate expanding that presence where appropriate. Not “available if needed.” Not “assigned to a cluster.” Not “call a hotline.” On-site.
If the county executive wants to talk about “layers,” then put the strongest layer back in the building. If the superintendent says, “everything’s on the table,” then stop treating SROs as the one tool you are not allowed to mention without getting scolded by activists.
Elrich’s message asks for continued dialogue. Fine. Here is the first sentence of that dialogue: Bring back real SROs, on-site, in our schools.
Because the next time we get “fortunate” and avoid a fatality, we might not be so lucky.
Endnotes (with URL links)
Carol Hughes is a contributor for Direct Line News. She can be reached at Carol.Hughes@mcgopclub.com
Direct Line News is a Maryland-based free-access publication committed to the Republican reform tradition.