Judge Blasts MCPS Over Disability Law

Listen to this article now
POWERED BY DIGITAL PIZZA AUDIO
00:00 05:16
Reading Time: 4 minutes
Montgomery County Public Schools sign with headline reading “Judge Blasts MCPS Over Disability Law” and a subheading about special-education placement, parental rights, and accountability.
Profile photo of Scott Marshall
Scott Marshall Junior Writer

Some government programs matter more for process than for the final decision. Special education is one of them.

Parents of children with disabilities already spend an enormous amount of time fighting for services, attending meetings, reviewing evaluations, and trying to figure out what will give their child the best chance to succeed. The last thing they should have to wonder is whether the school system made up its mind before they ever walked into the room.

Yet that disturbing picture emerges from a recent report involving Montgomery County Public Schools.

According to The Banner, Maryland Administrative Law Judge Willis Gunther Baker sharply criticized MCPS after reviewing how the school system handled the placement of a 6-year-old boy with significant emotional and behavioral disabilities. The judge described documents developed under Chief Student Support Officer Margaret Cage as a “blatant attempt to circumvent” requirements of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.[1]

Those are unusually strong words from a judge.

The case centered on a disagreement between the child’s parents and MCPS. The parents believed their son needed a specialized nonpublic school. MCPS wanted to place him in one of its own special-education programs.

Disagreements like that happen. School officials don’t have to agree with parents automatically, and parents don’t automatically get whatever placement they request.

But they do have a right to participate meaningfully in the decision.

Federal regulations are quite clear. A child’s educational placement must be determined by a group that includes the parents and people who understand the child, the evaluation data, and the available placement options. The placement must be based on the student’s Individualized Education Program.[2]

In other words, an IEP meeting isn’t supposed to be theater.

If administrators have already decided which options are acceptable before parents and teachers meet, then something has gone badly wrong.

What makes this case even more troubling is the apparent connection to money.

The Banner reports that Montgomery County spent roughly $57 million in fiscal 2025 to place about 700 students in specialized nonpublic schools. According to the judge’s analysis, Cage began implementing a new approach related partly to managing the school system’s financial exposure from private placements and settlements.[1]

Let’s acknowledge something: $57 million is real money, and taxpayers have every right to expect MCPS to spend it responsibly.

But there is a difference between controlling costs and allowing cost concerns to dictate an individual child’s education.

If Montgomery County believes it’s spending too much on private placements, then county leaders should ask why so many families believe MCPS programs cannot adequately serve their children.

The district may need stronger specialized programs of its own. Staff needs improvement. Some services could be delivered more effectively. Those are legitimate questions.

The answer cannot be to narrow the choices available to an IEP team quietly.

The judge found that MCPS acted in bad faith and criticized the district’s arguments. She also questioned Cage’s credibility regarding documents staff used. Ultimately, the school system was ordered to place the boy in the school his parents had sought.[1]

MCPS disputes the judge’s characterization that a district policy existed. Officials say there was miscommunication, and the district issued new guidance emphasizing that placement decisions cannot be predetermined.[1]

That clarification is welcome. But it shouldn’t end the discussion.

The Montgomery County Board of Education should determine exactly what happened. Who wrote these directives? Who approved them? How many IEP teams operated under the same understanding? How many families may have been affected?

Those aren’t partisan questions. They’re accountability questions.

But conservatives should pay particular attention because this case touches on something Republicans have argued for years: parents must have a meaningful voice in their children’s education.

That principle becomes even more important when we’re talking about a child with disabilities.

The people sitting around an IEP table should be discussing one question above all others: What does this child need?

Not what is easiest for the bureaucracy.

Not what avoids an uncomfortable budget discussion.

And certainly not what somebody in the central office decided beforehand.

Parents shouldn’t have to fight City Hall or the school system’s central office to receive the process federal law already promises them.


Endnotes

1. The Banner “Judge blasts Montgomery County schools for ‘blatant attempt’ to dodge disability law.” Talia Richman, October 5, 2026. Reporting on the administrative law decision, MCPS placement practices, district response, and nonpublic-placement costs.
https://www.thebanner.com/education/k-12-schools/montgomery-county-schools-disability-law-decision-PM2BS4IVINE3HN67YBPZBKD7MU/

2. U.S. Department of Education Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 34 C.F.R. § 300.116, “Placements.” Federal regulation governing how educational placement decisions for children with disabilities must be made, including required parental participation and the relationship between placement and the student’s IEP.
https://sites.ed.gov/idea/regs/b/b/300.116

3. U.S. Department of Education “Return to School Roadmap: Development and Implementation of Individualized Education Programs.” Federal IDEA guidance explaining that placement decisions must include parents, must be individualized, and must conform to IDEA’s least-restrictive-environment requirements.
https://sites.ed.gov/idea/idea-files/return-to-school-roadmap-development-and-implementation-of-ieps/

About The Author

Scroll to Top