Governor Wes Moore just put his signature on two new “reform” bills that sound wonderful if you don’t think too hard: the Expungement Reform Act of 2025 and the Maryland Second Look Act. Both go into effect October 1, 2025, and both represent the same magical thinking that has turned once-great American cities into cautionary tales.
Let’s start with the Expungement Reform Act. Under this law, the process for wiping away certain misdemeanor convictions will be “streamlined” — because heaven forbid there be too many speed bumps between committing a crime and getting a clean record. The bill also adds in “successful probation completion” as a factor.
Translation? If you manage not to mess up after committing a crime — congratulations! You might get to act like it never happened.
In a world where we claim to value accountability, this isn’t a step forward. It’s a legally sanctioned eraser.
Then there’s the Maryland Second Look Act, which sounds like something a bureaucrat dreamed up at a diversity, equity, and inclusion seminar.
Under this law, people who committed crimes between the ages of 18 and 25 — and have been locked up for 20 years or more — can now petition for sentence reductions.
“Second look” at what exactly? Their victims never got a second look. Families who lost loved ones don’t get to refile petitions for a second chance at life.
The argument, of course, is that the brain isn’t fully developed until age 25.
Here’s the thing: neither is my backhand on the tennis court, but if I hit someone with my car, I don’t get to say, “Hey, still maturing!”
Eighteen is old enough to vote, serve in the military, sign contracts, and run for office. It’s old enough to know that shooting someone, assaulting someone, or committing armed robbery is wrong. Always has been. Always will be.
Governor Moore, to no one’s surprise, framed these bills as part of “giving people a second chance.”
In reality, they represent a government more invested in rehabilitating its worst citizens than protecting its best ones. It’s not “justice” if the only people getting new chances are the ones who threw away their first ones.
This is how Maryland loses — not with a bang, but with a slow, systematic lowering of standards. We tell victims their suffering is negotiable, that consequences are fluid, and that time served is just a suggestion.
And for what? Political points at ribbon-cutting ceremonies?
Mark your calendars for October 1, Maryland.
That’s when the state’s message becomes official: If you do wrong, don’t worry — we’ll be happy to “take a second look.”
Some of us, meanwhile, are still waiting for a first look at leadership that actually puts law-abiding citizens first.
Direct Line News is a Maryland-based free-access publication committed to the Republican reform tradition.
About The Author
